Will the new VED rates reduce CO2 emissions?

3RD APR 2017

Changes to Car Tax came into effect on the 1st April 2017. In this article we ask whether the system is conducive with the Government's policy of reducing C02.

VED: What are the changes?

Any vehicle registered on or after April 1st 2017 are subject to new Vehicle Excise Duty (VED) rates, based on CO2 emission bandings. Previously, tax was due on vehicles which emit 101g/km CO2 and above. The rates for new vehicles that fall into these bands have now increased. Vehicles registered before April 1st 2017 pay the previous rates.

New tax bands are introduced for vehicles with CO2 emissions between 1 and 100 g/km which were previously exempt.

Finally, regardless of CO2, if a vehicle costs £40,000 or more then it is subject to a new premium rate billed annually.

Volkswagen Golf GTE

First year rate rises disproportionately for lower emitting vehicles

Vehicles with emissions between 76-130k/gm which previously paid nothing in the first year are now faced with a bill of between £100-160. This increase is disproportionate to ‘mid-tier’ emitting vehicles, such as those that emit 145k/gm, which rises from £145 to £200.

That means lower emitting vehicles proportionately have had a bigger increase in first year VED rates than some higher polluting vehicles.

Nissan Qashqai 4wd

Petrol and Diesel vehicles pay the same rate of VED from the second year despite CO2 differences

Unless the vehicle costs over £40,000, all petrol and diesel vehicles pay the same £140 rate of VED from year 2 onwards.

That means that a small-capacity Ford Fiesta pays the same amount of annual VED from year 2 as a Land Rover Evoque.

Alternatively fueled vehicles like a hybrid Toyota Prius get a £10 reprieve and pay £130.

Ford Fiesta

Lower emission, high value vehicles pay more than high emission, low value vehicles

Vehicles with lower-emissions and a higher value are worse off against a lower priced vehicle with much higher emissions.

A car worth £40,000 or more with 100g/KM costs £1470 over a 4 year period.

Compare that to a vehicle that is worth less than £40,000 that emits more than 151g/KM which costs £920 over the same period.

That means that a vehicle with 50% higher emissions pays nearly 50% less VED on the new scheme just because it costs less.

BMW 3 Series

Zero emission vehicles with high values pay more too

Pure Electric Vehicles with zero emissions are required to pay no first year or annual VED retaining all the benefits of the previous system – except of course, if they cost over £40,000. In this case there is a £310 annual ‘premium’ rate of VED due.

That means a total VED spend of £620 over 3 years - that’s more than vehicles that cost less than £40,000 that emit 150 g/KM of CO2 would pay over the same period (£480).

Tesla S

How consistent are the VED changes with the Government’s policy of CO2 reduction?

Car Tax is a method for funding much-needed developments to our road and transport networks however the government has the publically stated aim of reducing CO2. One way then can do this is through incentivising the use of more eco-friendly vehicles.

The examples shown above demonstrate both the complexity of the new system and that the Government’s intentions appear to be at odds with each other. Such measures as the introduction of the £40,000 banding ignore CO2 reduction altogether.

Neal Francis, PVM Divisional Managing Director, commented ‘We would urge the government to re-evaluate how the structure operates in practice as until 2020 there is little incentive for drivers to select lower emission vehicles which will compromise the Government’s ability to achieve their stated goal of ongoing CO2 reduction.’

What do you think? Are the new V.E.D. rates a step in the right direction or should the Government rethink their policy? Let us know on our Twitter or LinkedIn page.